Community MetaCouncil's Game of the Year Awards 2025

Le Pertti

120 fps gamer boi
Oct 10, 2018
9,850
25,795
113
46
Paris, France
lepertti.com
goty2025votingbanner.webp

Welcome to MetaCouncil's Annual Game of the Year voting! Vote for five of your favorite games of 2025.




Check out our GOTY's for past years:
GOTY 2024
GOTY 2023
GOTY 2022
GOTY 2021
GOTY 2020
GOTY 2019
GOTY 2018

Rules are as follows:
The categories for voting are:
  • Game of the Year 2025 Award (main award)
  • Best of Last Year (optional)
  • Best Game You Didn't Play (new this year!) (optional)
  • Ongoing Game of the Year (optional)
  • Early Access of the Year (optional)
  • Best Soundtrack (optional)
  • Best Old Game (optional)
  • Turd of the Year (optional)
Rules specific to the main award:
  • Up to 5 choices can be submitted (ranked voting without point):
    • 1st Choice
    • 2nd Choice
    • 3rd Choice
    • 4th Choice
    • 5th Choice
  • You can submit fewer than 5 games, but you must submit at least 1 game as your 1st choice.
  • For the 1st Choice, you have to write a short text to explain why you have chosen it as your GOTY. It could be a sentence.
  • Do not submit the same game for several Choices of the main award.
Eligibility criteria for each category:
  • GOTY 2025 Award:
    • Any game fully released in 2025 is eligible.
    • This includes remakes and remasters, provided that they are new to your platform of choice. (For example: Indiana Jones new to PlayStation)
    • Episodic content is eligible if the last episode was released in 2025.
    • As MetaCouncil is a predominantly English language website, any game getting an English translation in the correct time frame can be eligible.
    • As to be clear, you can choose VR games for the GOTY category.
    • You can submit games from any PC store front and Console and even Phones.
  • Best of Last Year
    • Any game from 2024 that you played this year.
    • Otherwise the rules are essentially the same as for the main award.
  • Best Game Not Played
    • Any Game Released in 2025 that you really wanted to play but for some reason didn't.
  • Ongoing Game of the Year
    • Any game fully released prior to 2025 which received content updates in 2025 is eligible.
    • New content can be in the form of patches, DLC or general updates, but not bug fixes.
    • This includes massive expansions, as long as it requires the base game.
  • Early Access of the Year
    • Any game released into Early Access (or equivalent) in 2025 is eligible.
  • Best Soundtrack
    • Did any 2025 game have a stellar soundtrack? You can now vote for that too!
  • Best Old Game
    • Maybe you played a non 2025 game this year and it completely blew everything else away and you want to give some acknowledgment.
  • Turd of the Year
    • Any game fully released in 2025 is eligible. We're looking for the worst games.

To Vote send a PM to me Le Pertti with the subject GOTY2025 and format you message as follows:

Code:
GOTY 2025
1. Game Title
2. Game Title
3. Game Title
4. Game Title
5. Game Title

Short Motivation for GOTY:
Your awesome text.

Best of Last Year:
Game Title

Best Game Not Played:
Game Title

Ongoing:
Game Title

Early Access of the year:
Game Title

Best Soundtrack:
Game Title

Best Old Game:
Game Title

Turd of the Year:
Game Title



Deadline:
January 15th 2026
 
Last edited:
Me getting ready to vote Civilization VII as turd of the year.

Rubbing Hands Disagree GIF
 
I don't play as many current year games as last year. For whatever reason. :flare_lmao:

As it currently stands, I can count the number of games released in 2025 that I've completed in one hand. And the closest thing to a GOTY in my mind is still a work in progress.

Well, I still have four weeks to work on it, I guess. :flare_bath:
 
1. Kingdom Come: Deliverance II
2. Last of Us: Part II (PC)
3. Mafia: Old Country
4. Hell is Us
5. South of Midnight

Best Soundtrack:
Kingdom Come: Deliverance II

Best Old Game:
Aliens: Dark Descent

Turd of the Year:
Lost Records: Bloom and Rage
 
Done.

I never really play latest games because of exploitative regional pricings or my hardware not matching current specs anymore.
I played many then-current releases last year. This year, barely (except for fiddling around with a couple, on my friend's Xbox and PS5.). One that I did play substantially, deserves more recognition.
 
I voted like this:
GOTY 2025
1. Clair Obscur: Expedition 33
2. Hollow Knight: Silksong
3. AI LIMIT
4. Ender Magnolia: Blood in the Mist
5. The Outer Worlds 2

Short Motivation for GOTY:
Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 is one of the best JRPG style games I have played, and it is very surprising to see a game with so many strengths coming from a new developer with no track record.

The story and characters are simply better than in most other games in the genre. I am quite good at losing interest in games and disappearing them in my massive queue of things to do later, but after a brief opening section with slightly annoying city exploration content, the game delivers one of the most enticing and one of the most well paced main story progressions that I have experienced in a role playing game. Despite the strong drive forward in the story, the game is at the same time subtle in how it fleshes out the world building and the character back stories. The voice acting and the ending(s) are incredible as well. There are no weaknesses in the story department in this game!

The gameplay is great as well, but has some minor frustrations. Basically, the gameplay systems are maximalist in the vein of a main line Final Fantasy game. You can except an old school world map system, loads of side quests, loads of optional areas, and a complex combat system that synergizes with a lot of items that you will find through the extensive exploration content that the game has to offer. The combat system is turn-based, but includes timing based button prompts that have to be used defensively, and can also be used to enhance offensive abilities. It is a quite interesting system, but it mostly comes off as a well made turn based JPRG combat system. The frustrations in the system consist of a lot of really difficult enemy encounters that are placed near the main path of areas, and it is often unclear if you should tackle the challenges right away or if you should leave them for endgame cleanup duties. A couple of such encounters throughout the game would have been fine, but in this game most areas have one or two of them ...

The graphics and music are fantastic, and perfectly complement the great story that the game has to offer. I played the game in 4k DLSS quality mode with DLSS4 forced through the Nvidia app, and the graphics never disappointed.

I would highly recommend the game to fans of the JRPG genre.

Best of Last Year:
The Legend of Zelda: Echoes of Wisdom

Best Game Not Played:
Avowed

Ongoing:
Teardown

Best Soundtrack:
Clair Obscur: Expedition 33

Best Old Game:
Super Mario Galaxy 2

Turd of the Year:
Baby Steps
 
I need to make a decision I don't think I ever had to make before regarding the GotY vote.
Usually, I've either completed all games that would be candidate for my GotY, or not even (often remotely :P) gotten to them yet.
But this year, I'm in the middle of Expedition 33, and if it holds up (even accounting for the falloff I expect in almost every single RPG towards the end) it will easily make it into my top 5.

I lean towards including it.
 
GOTY 2025
1. Look Outside
2. Clair Obscur: Expedition 33
3. Hollow Knight: Silksong
4. Hades II

Look Outside is a $10 RPGMaker game that caught my eye while I was browsing the Steam store during the Winter Sale. I found the artstyle and premise interesting, plus I've heard some good things about it so I bought it. What I thought would be a short little RPG turned into a 60+ hour obsession, despite technically beating the game 20 hours in. The game is full of secrets, mysteries to solve, endearing characters, funny interactions, unsettling horrors, and I was so enthralled by its setting. Sure, I had lots of fun with Clair Obscur and Silksong, but those 2 have gotten enough praise already and I think more people should check out Look Outside. Such a charming and thought-provoking game should not fade to obscurity.

Best Soundtrack:
Clair Obscur: Expedition 33

Best Old Game:
Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice
 
header.jpg

1. Fantasy Life i: The Girl Who Steals Time

This thing is pure distilled joy in game form. The art direction, menu UIs, music...all of it packaged together feels so snug & warm. Energy that's pure & joyous w/o being saccharine. A tough needle to thread that FI pulls off with an easy confidence.

Feels quite DQB2-adjacent in feel & form. The amount of content on offer impresses and I love that there's always multiple paths/goals that can be followed. Leading to a freeform sandbox vibe that invites the player to engage at a variety of mood levels.

Man what a soothing balm.


header.jpg

2. Escape From Duckov

It's amazing when media can successfully combine two disparate tones into a cohesive whole. Duckov sports both whimsy & depth.

Looks gorgeous and plays like a dream. There's a Dysmantle-like simplicity with the top-down presentation, the playfield reads clean. And still tactical depth remains with diverse loadouts, skill trees and base expansion. A refreshing combo of charm & mechanical engagement.

When I look at the inspiration with Tarkov, I see an ambitious & complex military im-sim shooter. Incredible for the target audience but for me a bit too mechanically & competitively intense. Duckov enters the chat with a single-player approximation that feels more breezy without sacrificing any of the essentials.


header.jpg

3. Schedule I

Somewhere along the way Schedule I went from a pretty dang accomplished meme game to a legit awesome real game.

Great moment to moment gameplay loops & progression systems, fun world to explore, really nice gameplay feel (upgrade your skateboard asap!). This thing is WAY more thoughtful & polished than one may imagine on the surface. Really nails that "just one more day" progression loop of classics like Stardew, etc.

The WarioWare-like minigames for product packaging & distribution are a mechanical stroke of genius!


header.jpg

4. Sunken Engine

SE is a shipyard sim with a creative Lovecraft twist. Sports killer artwork and the gameplay loop has surprising depth for a traditional "lite" job sim (think Gas Station Simulator).

Along with the genre staples like base expansion and skill upgrade trees there's also nice side activities like fishing and fish-market stall sales.

I love that you have to manage your sanity as well, you start seeing strange visions as it decays. This thing really nails the creep-vibe atmosphere, it feels far more authentic to the themes than you'd imagine given the genre.

All told it's a super-creative twist on an established genre with nice production values and an attractive price.


header.jpg

5. Little Rocket Lab

Stardew meets Factorio-lite is about as apt as you're gonna get with this one. A great hybrid for genre fans.

Very friendly from the jump with a cozy story campaign attached to help with user direction.

The overall more relaxed vibe makes it a great palate cleanser when weighed against the math-engineering trainers like Factorio, lol.

header.jpg

6. Tainted Grail: The Fall of Avalon / Sanctuary of Sarras DLC

It's AA Black Metal Skyrim and it's absolutely glorious.

Great art style, thoughtful lore from TTRPG roots, and most importantly it captures that Bethesda rpg sandbox vibe that so few releases seem able to replicate. With a bonus perk of weighty combat.

Def. got that grim-dark energy, but it's played with such earnestness that instead of being cheeseball it won me over.


header.jpg

7. Trails in the Sky 1st Chapter

I do have a soft spot for the original Trails 1st. Steam says I played around 25 hrs. back in 2017, but I obviously never finished it and don't remember much beyond positive vibes.

But man this remake is just so immediately attractive on first blush. Maybe I haven't been keeping up with modern JRPG design 'cause this production is just so lush & colorful. It reads so clean, which I actually do remember in the small details found in the original, such as set dressings found in shops, etc (ie unique geometry for a random apple barrel).

Another neat touch is the character portraits in the dialogue panels. Guess I'm used to them being static pics normally, but here there's just a touch of animation to them, a slight shift in hair that's tasteful & subtle. Suggesting animation but not overdoing it.

Great realtime/turn-based hybrid combat system.

Warm-blanket RPG'ing at its finest!


header.jpg

8. Heart of the Machine

Sleek, stylish & sophisticated.

Heart of the Machine is a tactics, 4X, city-builder, colony sim, and RPG.

Impressive genre mashup and the freshest entry in the Strat scene in quite some time.

Feels like a classic in the making.


header.jpg

9. MIRO

Miro feels like the early days of No Man's Sky in regards to planetary exploration, the walking-sim element with discovery & chill vibes. Yet this is structured with a story & defined goals. Nice tech upgrade paths compliment the exploration element, giving purpose in resource collection.

It feels a bit like a matured Proteus in presentation but with distinct story beats & direction. Has that lo-fi PS1-era art direction if that's your thing (it def. is mine). While planets you explore are procedural, they remain static with unique resource types & structures that you can revisit for upgrade materials. So it doesn't feel random in the traditional sense.

Bonus props for QoL features like toggles to both auto-walk & auto-run. Seems like a small thing but it makes a difference at the maps are quite sprawling and thanks to an upgradable compass that populates POIs, it never feels aimless.


header.jpg

10. VEIN

VEIN is a surprisingly atmospheric run at Project Zomboid. And it looks to have amazing potential.

The zombie survival-sandbox genre is a crowded market on PC so differentiation can be challenging. VEIN brings the goods in combining the complex nature of Zomboid with a fresh first-person perspective. So a bit like 7 Days with more depth.

It's coming from a 2-person dev team who appear to have a firm grasp on the appeal of titles like Zomboid. The character stats (physical/mental health), skill development & world interactivity is on the upper-end of the spectrum, making the space feel dynamic and full of possibility. After all these years it's wild to play out the survival gameplay loops unique to Zomboid in a fully realized 3D space, one that can be quite visually striking at times.

Character movement & combat feel responsive if a bit pedestrian. You can set zombie pop size in new game creation, but being 3D it feels like population sizes will never match the hoards in Zomboid. Menus navigation is smart & snappy (very important with high-volume inventory management). The map is huge with a nice variety of natural & inhabited environments.

It's firmly in Early Access so you're getting in on the ground floor. But in the here and now, it feels well worth one's time & attention.

Other notable titles I really dug this year that make me wish there were a Top 20:

Easy Delivery Co.
Quasimorph
Obenseuer
AutoForge
Card Survival: Fantasy Forest
Two Point Museum
Approaching Infinity
Disillusion ST
ENA: Dream BBQ
Cape Hideous
 
This is my top 10 from 2025, we had a lot of interesting games and I can't wait to see the results

Top 10
1. Clair Obscur: Expedition 33
2. Hollow Kinght: Silksong
3. The Roottrees are Dead
4. Citizen Sleeper 2: Starward Vector
5. Pipistrello and the Cursed Yoyo
6. Promise Mascot Agency
7. Blue Prince
8. Ender Magnolia: Bloom in the Mist
9. Powerwash Simulator 2
10. Ball x Pit

More people should give Pipistrello a chance it's a great zelda-like/metroidvania
 
I should post my votes.

GOTY 2025
1. Clair Obscur: Expedition 33
2. Hollow Knight: Silksong
3. Dispatch
4. Final Fantasy Tactics: The Ivalice Chronicles
5. Suikoden I&II HD Remaster: Gate Rune and Dunan Unification Wars

Had I finished Trails 1st before the break when I voted, I might have put it above Suikoden there but alas.
 
A patientgamer vote. ;)

1. Clair Obscur: Expedition 33

Short Motivation for GOTY:
A pure showcase of talent, creativity and sincerity, Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 is easily one of the best RPG in the modern era. It is a testimony of videogame as an art form.

Best of Last Year:
Reverse Collapse: Codename Bakery

I thought Expedition 33 would be my favorite game of 2025, until... Reverse Collapse. The polish is truly mind-blowing - every gameplay element is adjusted to near perfection. An absolutely brutal, but fair, tactical game, with a well-written story and a great cast of characters. It is a game that deserves to be played by every tactical game lover.

Best Game Not Played:
Cronos: The New Dawn

Something about Cronos intrigues me a lot - maybe it's the dark and mystery environment, or the apparently high difficulty, or the protag who is completely covered up and faces the darkness in a stoic manner. Definitely going to check it out once I have upgraded my hardware.

Best Soundtrack:
Clair Obscur: Expedition 33

Best Old Game:
Reverse Collapse: Codename Bakery
 
I managed to play a surprisingly large number of games released in 2025 in 2025. In other years I sometimes had a hard time even filling up 5 slots. In my actual votes I just cut this off at 5, although honestly the order is somewhat arbitrary beyond 3rd place or so.

1. ELDEN RING NIGHTREIGN
Nightreign is not a game for everyone, and the roguelike aspect isn't generally even something I appreciate, but when I think of everything released in 2025 and the experience I had with it, it does stand out. Its design leads to plenty of interesting and memorable co-op shenanigans, from coming up with a daring plan just before the night moves in and barely making it to dying to the Nightlord when it has 5 hp remaining. Twice. But anyway, it's exciting.

2. Hollow Knight: Silksong
3. Clair Obscur: Expedition 33
4. Ender Magnolia: Bloom in the Mist
5. Tainted Grail: The Fall of Avalon
6. The Hundred Line -Last Defense Academy-
7. POPUCOM
8. SILENT HILL f
9. Lego Voyagers
10. AI LIMIT


Best of Last Year
Dungeons of Hinterberg


This one has a fun setting/story, varied puzzles and level design, and satisfying moment-to-moment gameplay. It also doesn't overstay its welcome. Very solid.

Best Game Not Played
Avowed


I think this is the most likely game released in 2025 that would have made it on my list had I played it already.

Ongoing
Reverse: 1999


This has been my guilty pleasure since fall. It has some genuinely interesting world-building and story beats, and what makes it actually playable (for me as someone who has dropped GaaS titles almost entirely) is that it doesn't demand several hours of engagement a week to keep up to date with all the meaningful content and "optimize" your gameplay. It obviously fits the "ongoing" award since, being GaaS, there's a substantial new story content chunk every few weeks.

Best Soundtrack
Clair Obscur: Expedition 33


I haven't completed E33 yet, but especially the soundtrack has actively stood out to me more than in any game I can recall since Nier: Automata (and Ar Tonelico before that).
 
GOTY 2025
1. Xenoblade Chronicles X: Definitive Edition (Monolith Soft)
It is a bit out of the ordinary for me to choose a console game for an GOTY entry, let alone one that is weaker in narrative compared to the other entries in my ballot. However, XenobladeX's sense of exploration and wonder stands apart. While the open world experience is not entirely unique, the sense of progression is nearly unmatched, even when compared with the other Xenoblade games. While personally the combat system wasn't my cup of tea, the world of Mira is filled with adventures and secrets that makes this game much greater than the sum of its parts. A modern classic in almost every sense of the world.

2. The Hundred Line -Last Defense Academy- (Too Kyo Games)
I don't know if this game is a kamige like Kodaka said, but it surely was a ride. There are some of the highest highs in there, particularly with the Comedy route, Killing Game route and S.F route, but it also has the lowest lows that I had to skip all the combat segments so that I won't burn myself out before I even finish the game. I wish the combat segments has more variety though, that is my main complaint.

3. Detective Instinct: Farewell, My Beloved (Armonica)
The core mystery is interesting, and I wish that it was longer and the investigations are more involved. The game took place in nearly a single location, much like how Hitchcock did it in The Lady Vanishes. The protagonists even have their own character developments, and I feel that it really struck a good balance between a relationship that is more than "just friends", but also without any romantic entanglements. A commendable effort, overall.


Best of Last Year:
Hookah Haze (ACQUIRE)
The bartending mechanics perhaps weren't as strong as its source of inspiration, but the short narrative really hits the right notes for me. There's something in there about trauma and found families and all that. But most of all, it's about acceptance and making the best out of a difficult situation and how everybody deserve companionships and understanding. A hidden gem.


Best Game Not Played:
Milano's Odd Job Collection (Victor Interactive Software/Hilltop Works)
The life sim mechanics reminded me a lot of Boku No Natsuyasumi 2 that I played the hell out of on last year's summer. Hopefully I will have time to play it before this summer is over.

Best Soundtrack:
Xenoblade Chronicles X: Definitive Edition (Hiroyuki Sawano)
The moment we took flight in the game for the first time and “Don't Worry” starts playing in the background is now one of my most treasured gaming experiences.

Best Old Game:
Cyberpunk 2077 (CD PROJEKT RED)
I think one of the most important themes that Cyberpunk 2077 was trying to impart is how we as individuals should be able to live on our own terms, and being able to live with the consequences of our decisions, whether it is good or bad. In the nearly 300 hours of playthrough, I agonise a lot over these decisions. Whether to go full stealth or guns blazing, to throw my lot in with one faction over another, to keep a secret or reveal it for financial reasons, whether to side with Songbird or Reed. All of these things are something I really enjoyed in an RPG: meaningful choices. Choices that defines these characters, and reflects how one views the world and oneself.
 
So...I missed the cutoff, because I thought its the end of this day .... oops.
I was still planning to play a few more hours of the games at #5, since I couldnt decide – here's where I was:

GOTY 2025

1. Pocket City 2
2. Stellar Blade
3. The Last of Us Part II Remastered
4. Mafia: The Old Country
5. Atomfall
5. The Outer Worlds 2
5. Echoes of the End

Short Motivation for GOTY:
It's a really good and simple city builder that has surprising depth (in terms of what you can do in your city)

Best of Last Year:
Tiny Glade

Best Game Not Played:


Ongoing:


Early Access of the year:


Best Soundtrack:


Best Old Game:
SimCity 3000

Turd of the Year:
 
I also missed the deadline.

GOTY 2025
1. Hollow Knight: Silksong
2. The End is Nigh: Shattered Spectrum (mod)
3. Lies of P: Overture
4. Absolum
5. Hades II
If Mod No Count: Real 5. DOOM: The Dark Ages
If Expansion Dependent on Ineligible Game No Count: Real 5. Rocket Boots Mania

Short Motivation for GOTY:
I wasn't anticipating Silksong. Played Hollow Knight and finished it after bouncing off of the game several times, but wasn't super in to it. Tried Silksong on a whim awhile after release. Turned out that I loved it. I have been playing many precision platformers and Soulslikes the past few years which has pivoted my taste in such a way that Silksong grabbed on to my face and held on tight. In addition to being inside my genre wheelhouse, my explorer side was well fed.

Best of Last Year:
Yellow Taxi Goes Vroom

Best Game Not Played:
Look Outside

Ongoing:
Lies of P: Overture

Early Access of the year:
Deadlock

Best Soundtrack:
South of Midnight (the bespoke folk music was cool)

Best Old Game:
Warhammer 40,000: Darktide

Turd of the Year:
Pirates VR: Jolly Roger (still enjoyed myself)